In college writing classes, we sit in a tight circle, facing each other. Sometimes, we critique our own works; other times we discuss writing. But one time — and only once — everyone raised their voices against what I suggested.
I disagreed with the author using the word “said” for every single dialogue tag. I raised my hand and said something like, “It’d be better to mix up the dialogue tags every once in a while. If you use the word ‘said’ every time, the author is going to skim over it and—”
“That’s the point!” many of my classmates exclaimed at the same time.
My professor even had a smile on his face like my comment was laughable.
But I continued. “If you mix up dialogue tags every once in a while, you could add some more context and emotion to what’s going on. ‘That’s stupid,’ he said has a different context than ‘That’s stupid,’ he laughed. Using other dialogue tags could add more to the story.”
I think back to that moment from time to time when editing or reading. Do I use certain dialogue tags too much? Should I use the word “said” more? I definitely don’t agree with having a word to be skimmed over or ignored.
What do you think? Leave a comment below!