Terrible critiques vs amazing critiques

Every writer needs critiques. As I’ve posted here before, critiques from beta readers help writers improve their work. But that doesn’t mean that every critique a writer gets is helpful.

Critiques point out what may not be working well in a story. But they’re all suggestions. No one has to follow word-for-word with what every critique says. Some critiques aren’t good at all. Here’s some tips to help tell the difference between terrible and amazing critiques:

Terrible critiques:

Curse words (directed toward the writing or the writer)

Believe it or not, I’ve been cussed at in a critique. The critic told me that my chapter reminded him of another work he hated (and cussed at), which I felt was directed toward me. No one should be cussing at you or your work at all. Throwing cuss words around does not help anyone.

No suggestions (that are meaningful)

I used to get no suggestions all the time in high school. My classmates thought since I was a writer, they didn’t have to critique well. So, they pretended to critique my work. I’d get comments such as “wonderful” or “you did great here” or “all correct.” None of their comments had any real suggestions of how to improve my writing. Some writers have done this to me as well. It’s more common than you’d think.

Even great stories, such as Percy Jackson and the Olympians, have suggestions to improve it. No written work is perfect.

Bring nothing but brutal (even if it’s directed toward the work)

Having your work critiqued can feel like a personal attack. Some critics critique every small thing they find. Instead suggestions, they nitpick everything without much or any praise at all.

This can cause the writer to have more stress and self-doubt than needed.

Amazing critiques:

Suggestions (for the story)

Most advanced critics will give some suggestions to help out. For example, instead of pointing out that the sentence doesn’t make sense, they’ll give an example of how to fix it. Critics don’t do this to everything, but they do it to a good amount.

Praise (for the writer)

Advanced critics also praise the author, usually toward the beginning. In my class, everyone had to say something good about the story that was different from anyone else.

Since critiques are personal, it’s helpful to remind writers what’s great about his/her/their work. It’s also easier to understand critiques if the writer already has faith in his or herself.

Did I leave anything out? Comment below!

7 thoughts on “Terrible critiques vs amazing critiques

  1. Cussing? Sounds more like an online troll than a professional editor. That stinks. The point of editing is to help writers succeed–not make them regret writing! That’s why when I edit, I make sure there’s some actionable suggestions for the writer, but balance it with genuine compliments. That’s at least what I value. ❤

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s what I do too. When I edit, I mix in suggestions, grammar changes, and compliments all together. I never want to discourage a writer from writing. Writing is too much of a beautiful craft for that.


  2. Wow…cussing? That’s horrid.

    I can really relate to having someone critique your work and give nothing of value…

    I once asked someone to critique something. I told them that it was in VERY ROUGH form. It was actually a NaNoWrimo novel written in traditional NaNo form.
    Paragraphs were a mess-it had not been edited for typos-I had not organized the chapters and I stated that. I just wanted a general critique of the story-just the basic story.

    What I got was a rip-in of just what I said to ignore….sigh…

    Anyhow-that’s a writer’s life.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Some of my NaNoWriMo stories are rough too. One of them mentioned a witch in the first chapter, but everyone else in the entire novel was human. The person who was hinted at being a witch ended up being human. It was all a big mess. But those novels are supposed to be messy since you can’t edit them until they’re done. – But, it’s a writer’s life for me.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s